The Fate of Gustav Shpet’s translation of The Phenomenology of Spirit (Methodological Remarks)
Reviews
Readers community rating
0.0 (0 votes)


Views
892


Downloads
61
UDC
Издательство
Date of publication
17.05.2019
Public year
2019
DOI
10.31857/S004287440004797-1
The Fate of Gustav Shpet’s translation of The Phenomenology of Spirit (Methodological Remarks)
Читать книгу   Download pdf
О чем книга?

April 2019 marks the 140th anniversary of the birth of the Russian philosopher Gustav Gustavovich Shpet. In 1937, shortly before his execution, he completed a translation of Hegel's “The Phenomenology of Spirit”, that was published 60 years ago in 1959. The fate of this translation will be discussed in this paper. The preface to the publication compares the critical remarks to the edited translation of "The Phenomenology of Spirit" (1959), made by researchers in different years, and the 1937 translation of G.G. Shpet.It is shown that the stylistic, terminological and textual inaccuracies of the 1959 translation revealed during the subsequent reprints and research reprints do not refer to G. Shpet's translation work, but to the editing of the editorial team, which included B.Yu. Sliver (general edition), M.I. Itkin (verification of translation), M.P. Baskin, E.V. Ilyenkov, M.F. Ovsyannikov, A.I. Rubin, I.G. Khanjyan (reviewing of translation materials and work on terminology refinement). Below are published the materials on the history of this translation, that remained in the archive of Scientific-Research Department of Manuscripts of the Russian State Library: 1) the letters by daughter of G.G. Shpet, Lenora Gustavovna, to the independent expert, bibliographer, philosopher Pavel Khristoforovich Kananov, in which are described the attempts to save Shpet’s translation from editorial corrections; 2) remarks of the correction of the translation of Hegel’s “The Phenomenology of Spirit” made by P. Kh. Kananov; 3) draft (handwritten) variant of the Translator’s Preface by G.G. Shpet.

Об авторах
References

1. Gegel' 1913 – Gegel' G.V.F. Fenomenologiya dukha / Per. pod red. Eh.L. Radlova. SPb.: Tip. Akts. obsch. «Brokgauz-Efron», 1913 [Hegel, Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Die Phanomenologie des Geistes (Russian translation, 1913)].

2. Gegel' 1937 – Gegel' G.V.F. Fenomenologiya dukha [Perevod s nemetskogo, sdelannyj G.G. Shpetom. 1936–1937. Mashinopis' s pravkami rukoj G.G. Shpeta] // OR RGB. 718-9-1 [Hegel, Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Die Phanomenologie des Geistes (Russian translation, 1937)].

3. Gegel' 1959 – Gegel' G.V.F. Fenomenologiya dukha / Per. s nem. G.G. Shpeta. M.: Sotsehkgiz, 1959 [Hegel, Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Die Phanomenologie des Geistes (Russian translation, 1959)].

4. Gegel' 1992 – Gegel' G.V.F. Fenomenologiya dukha / Per. s nem. G. Shpeta, SPb.: Nauka, 1992. [Hegel, Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Die Phanomenologie des Geistes (Russian translation, 1959)].

5. Gegel' 2000 – Gegel' G.V.F. Fenomenologiya dukha / Otv. red. M.F. Bykova. M.: Nauka, 2000. [Hegel, Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Die Phanomenologie des Geistes (Russian translation, 1959)].

6. Shpet 1937a – Shpet G.G. Ot perevodchika [Chernovoj variant (rukopis'). V otdel'noj tetradi] // OR RGB. 718-8-7. L. 774–784 [Shpet, Gustav From the translator (In Russian)].

7. Shpet 1937b – Shpet G.G. Ot perevodchika. Chistovoj variant (rukopis') // OR RGB. 718-8-7. L. 769–773 [Shpet, Gustav G. From the Translator. Final Variant (Manuscript) (In Russian)].

8. Shpet 1937v – Shpet G.G. [Rabochie zametki ob osobennostyakh dialekticheskoj manery Gegelya. Avtograf chernilami i karandashom] // OR RGB. 718-8-7. L. 802–833 [Shpet Gustav G. Work Notes on the Peculiarities of Hegel's Dialectical Manner. An Autograph in Ink and Pencil (In Russian)].

9. Shpet 2010 – Shpet G.G. Opyt populyarizatsii filosofii Gegelya // Shpet G.G. Filosofskaya kritika: otzyvy, retsenzii, obzory / Otv. red.-sost. T.G. Schedrina. M.: ROSSPEhN, 2010. S. 222–252 [Shpet, Gustav G. The experience of popularization of the philosophy of Hegel (In Russian)].

10. Hegel, Georg Wilhelm Friedrich (1980) ‘Pha?nomenologie des Geistes’, Gesammelte Werke, hrsg. v. W. Bonsiepen, R. Heede, Felix Meiner Verlag, Hamburg.

11. Bykova 2000 – Bykova M.F. «Fenomenologiya dukha» kak nabrosok novoj kontseptsii sub'ektivnosti // Gegel' G.V.F. Fenomenologiya dukha / Otv. red. M.F. Bykova. M.: Nauka, 2000. S. 453–485.

12. Dmitrieva 2007 – Dmitrieva N.A. Russkoe neokantianstvo: «Marburg» v Rossii. Istoriko-filosofskie ocherki. M.: ROSSPEhN, 2007.

13. Korotkikh 2016 – Korotkikh V.I. Russkie perevody «Fenomenologii dukha» i problema peredachi gegelevskoj mysli v sovremennom filosofskom yazyke // Filosofskaya mysl'. 2016. № 8. http://e-notabene.ru/fr/article_19825.html

14. Kurennoj 2001 – Kurennoj V.A. «Sami veschi» Martina Khajdeggera // Issledovaniya po fenomenologii i filosofskoj germenevtike. Mn.: EGU, 2001. S. 6–44.

15. Sergeev, Slinin 1992 – Sergeev K.A., Slinin Ya.A. «Fenomenologiya dukha» Gegelya kak nauka ob opyte soznaniya // Gegel' G.V.F. Fenomenologiya dukha / Per. s nem. G. Shpeta; SPb.: Nauka, 1992. S. V–XLVII.

16. Shtorkh 2010 – Shtorkh M.G. Gustav Shpet i «Fenomenologiya dukha» Gegelya // «Fenomenologiya dukha» Gegelya v kontekste sovremennogo gegelevedeniya / Otv. red. N.V. Motroshilova. M.: Kanon+, 2010. C. 599–605.

17. Schedrina 2010a – Schedrina T.G. K voprosu o gegel'yanstve… Gustava Shpeta // «Fenomenologiya dukha» Gegelya v kontekste sovremennogo gegelevedeniya / Otv. red. N.V. Motroshilova. M.: Kanon+, 2010. C. 589–598.

18. Schedrina 2010b – Schedrina T.G. Perevod kak kul'turno-istoricheskaya problema (otechestvennye diskussii 1930–1950-kh godov i sovremennost') // Voprosy filosofii. 2010. № 12. S. 25–35.

19. Schedrina 2013 – Schedrina T.G. Gustav Shpet i shekspirovskij krug // Gustav Shpet i shekspirovskij krug. Pis'ma, dokumenty, perevody / Otv. red.-sost. T.G. Schedrina. M.; SPb.: Petroglif, 2013. C. –18.