Initial Sense of the Term “Protestantism”: A Historical and Philosophical Study
Initial Sense of the Term “Protestantism”: A Historical and Philosophical Study
Читать книгу   Download pdf
О чем книга?

The aim of the authors is the historical and philosophical verification of the Barthesian methodological technique of extrapolation of linguistic methods of analysis on the subject area of the philosophy and history of religion. The main task is to validate the possibility of using Barthesian semiology in the fields the history of religion and religious studies on the basis of the material coming from the field of Anglican and Protestant theology. The methodology includes comparative, historical-linguistic, and semantic analysis. The object of such a complex analysis is the semantic field (or the area of meanings) of the concept of "Protestantism». Using wide historical material, the authors demonstrate how, in the course of time, "degree zero" concepts and their "predicative" forms acquire meanings different from the original ones. A comparative analysis of some theological doctrines of Lutheranism, Calvinism, and Anglicanism using eight most representative parameters of comparison, such as authenticity, sufficiency, and clarity of Scripture; attitude to the Bloodless Sacrifice; recognition of the Real Presence of the Body and Blood of Christ in the Eucharistic elements; Church polity; Apostolic succession; Ordination, reveals the uniqueness of the historical phenomenon of the Church of England. The data obtained by the authors using the methodology of historical semantics and Barthesian semiology allow to draw a conclusion about the need to revise the classification criteria of the historical taxonomy of Christian confessions and denominations, identifying Anglicanism and of the Church of England into a separate taxon different from both Catholicism and ‘Protestantism’.

Об авторах
Davydov Ivan
Assistant Professor of the Faculty of Philosophy, Lomonosov Moscow State University
Ivan Fadeyev
Senior Research Fellow
Institute of World History, Russian Academy of Sciences
References

1. Apresyan Yu. D. Idei i metody sovremennoj strukturnoj lingvistiki (kratkij ocherk). M., 1966.

2. Balli Sh. Obschaya lingvistika i voprosy frantsuzskogo yazyka. M., 1955.

3. Bart R. Nulevaya stepen' pis'ma. M., 2008.

4. Bryondal' V. Struktural'naya lingvistika. - Zvegintsev V. A. Istoriya yazykoznaniya XIX–XX vekov v ocherkakh i izvlecheniyakh, ch. II. M., 1965, s. 94–100.

5. Brodel' F. Grammatika tsivilizatsij. M., 2014.

6. Brubejker R. Ehtnichnost' bez grupp. M., 2012.

7. Volodina M. N. Kognitivno-informatsionnaya priroda termina (na materiale terminologicheskikh sredstv massovoj informatsii). M., 2000.

8. Gurevich A. Ya. Problema genezisa feodalizma v Zapadnoj Evrope. - Izbrannye trudy. Drevnie germantsy. Vikingi. M. - SPb., 2014, s. 190.

9. Davydov I. P. Drevnie vostochnye tserkvi. - Istoriya religii, t. 2, s. 549–550.

10. Davydov I. P. Ehpistema miforituala. M., 2013.

11. Istoriya ponyatij, istoriya diskursa, istoriya mentaliteta. M., 2010.

12. Istoriya religij, v 2-kh t., t. 2. M., 2014.

13. Kaz'ma O. E., Puchkov P. I. Religioznye organizatsii sovremennogo mira. M., 2010.

14. Kniga soglasiya. Ehlektronnoe izdanie. 1998.

15. Kozellek R. Vvedenie. - Slovar' osnovnykh istoricheskikh ponyatij, v 2-kh t., t. I. M., 2014, s. 24.

16. Kosikov G. Rolan Bart – semiolog, literaturoved. - Bart R. Izbrannye raboty. Semiotika. Poehtika. M., 1994, s. 17, prim. 21.

17. Kuznetsov V. G. Zhenevskaya lingvisticheskaya shkola. Ot Sossyura k funktsionalizmu. M., 2010.

18. Kuznetsov V. G. Nauchnoe nasledie Zhenevskoj lingvisticheskoj shkoly. M., 2010.

19. Lebedev V. Yu., Prilutskij A. M. Semiozis i semiodinamika teologicheskikh i mifologicheskikh znakovykh sistem. Tver', 2010.

20. Lebedev V. Yu., Prilutskij A. M., Viktorov V. Yu. Religiovedenie: ucheb. dlya bakalavrov. M., 2013, s. 49–56.

21. Lotman Yu. M. Vnutri myslyaschikh mirov. SPb., 2015.

22. Osnovy religiovedeniya. M., 1994.

23. Osnovy religiovedeniya. M., 2005.

24. Ocherki istoricheskoj semantiki russkogo yazyka rannego Novogo vremeni. M., 2009.

25. Prilutskij A. M. Semiotika religii: filosofsko-religiovedcheskie issledovaniya. SPb., 2007.

26. Revunenkova N. Protestantizm. M., 2007.

27. Religiovedenie. M., 2006, s. 815–816.

28. Religiovedenie. M., 2012, s. 401–415.

29. Religiovedenie. Uchebn. posob. dlya studentov pedagogicheskikh vuzov. SPb., 2008, s. 437.

30. Savel'eva I. M., Poletaev A. V. Znanie o proshlom: teoriya i istoriya, v 2-kh t. T. 1. Konstruirovanie proshlogo; T. 2. Obrazy proshlogo. SPb., 2003–2006.

31. Skinner K. Istoki sovremennoj politicheskoj mysli, v 2-kh t. T. 1: Ehpokha Renessansa; T. 2: Ehpokha Reformatsii. M., 2018.

32. Sossyur F. de. Trudy po yazykoznaniyu. M., 1977.

33. Fadeev I. A. Problema anglikanskoj identichnosti: terminologicheskij i verouchitel'nyj aspekt. - Evraziya: dukhovnye traditsii narodov. 2012, № 4, s. 30–47.

34. Fadeev I. A. Tserkov' Anglii: problema konfessional'noj samoidentifikatsii v istoricheskoj perspektive. M., 2015.

35. Fuko M. Arkheologiya znaniya. SPb., 2012.

36. Fuko M. Slova i veschi. Arkheologiya gumanitarnykh nauk. SPb., 1994.

37. Shaff F. Istoriya Khristianskoj tserkvi, t. VII. SPb., 2009.

38. Scherba L. V. Yazykovaya sistema i rechevaya deyatel'nost'. M., 2004.

39. Ehvolyutsiya ponyatij v svete istorii russkoj kul'tury. M., 2012.

40. Yakobson R. O. Nulevoj znak. - Yakobson R. O. Izbrannye raboty. M., 1985, s. 222–230.

41. Andrewes L. Responsio ad Apologiam Cardinalis Bellarmini. Oxford, 1851.

42. Andrewes L. Sermon V; Sermon VI. – Ninety-Six Sermons by the Right Honourable and Reverend Father in God, Lancelot Andrewes, sometime Lord Bishop of Winchester, v. I. Oxford, 1878.

43. Andrewes L. Sermon II. – Ninety-Six Sermons by the Right Honourable and Reverend Father in God, Lancelot Andrewes, sometime Lord Bishop of Winchester, v. V. Oxford, 1880.

44. Answer of the Archbishops of England to The Apostolic Letter of Pope Leo XIII [Saepius Officio], r. 13–14.

45. Articuli Smalcaldici, III:X, col. 497.

46. Berkhof L. Systematic Theology. Grand Rapids, 1996.

47. Bramhall J. A Replication of the Bishop of Chalcedon’s Survey of the Vindication of the Church of England from Criminous Schism. - The Works, v. II, r. 88, 276.

48. Bramhall J. An Answer to M. De La Milletiere. - The Works, v. I, r. 8, 20.

49. Concordia Triglotta: Libri symbolici Ecclesiae Lutheranae. St. Louis, 1921.

50. Confessio Augustana XIV, col. 49.

51. Engelder Th. Popular symbolics: the doctrines of the churches of Christendom and of other religious bodies examined in the light of Scripture. Saint Louis, 1934.

52. Graebner A. L. Outlines of Doctrinal Theology. Saint Louis, 1910.

53. History of Troubles and Trials. - The Works of the Most Reverend Father in God, William Laud, D.D., Sometime Lord Archbishop of Canterbury, v. III. Oxford, 1853, r. 406–407.

54. Keble J. Adherence to the Apostolical Succession The Safest Course. - Tracts for the Times. V. I. 1833–1834. London - Oxford, 1834, r. 2.

55. Klaassen W. Anabaptism: Neither Catholic Nor Protestant. Waterloo, 1973.

56. Laud W. A Relation of The Conference between William Lawd, Then, Lrd. Arch-Bishop of St. Davids; now, Lord Arch-Bishop of Canberbvry: And Mr. Fisher the Jesuite, by the Command of King James of ever Blessed Memorie, r. 339–341.

57. MacCulloch D., Laven M., Duffy E. Recent Trends in the Study of Christianity in Sixteenth-Century Europe. - Renaissance Quarterly, 2006, № 59(3), r. 707.

58. Newman J. H. Thoughts on the Ministerial Commission Respectfully Addressed to the Clergy. - Tracts for the Times. V. I. 1833–1834. London-Oxford, 1834, r. 2.

59. Philosophy in History: Essays on the historiography of philosophy. Ed. by R. Rorty, J. B. Schneewind, Q. Skinner. Cambridge, 1984.

60. Schluesselburg C. Theologiae Calvinistarum Libri Tres; in quibus... demonstratur, eos de nulla fere doctrinae Christianae articulo rece sentire. Frankfurt, 1594.

61. Second Helvetic Confession XVIII.

62. Skinner Q. The Foundations of Modern Political Thought. V. 1. The Renaissance; V. 2. The Age of Reformation. Cambridge, 1978.

63. Taylor J. Of the Sacred Order and Offices of Episcopacy, by Divine Institution, Apostolical Tradition, and Catholic Practice. - The Whole Works of the Right Rev. Jeremy Taylor, D.D. Lord Bishop of Down, Connor, and Dromore, v. VII. London, 1822, r. 22.

64. The Works of the Most Reverend Father in God, William Laud, D.D., Sometime Lord Archbishop of Canterbury, v. VI (part I). Oxford, 1857.

65. Westminster Confession, Edinburgh, 1882.

66. Works of that Learned and Judicious Divine Mr. Richard Hooker with an Account of His Life and Death by Isaac Walton. Arranged by the Rev. John Keble MA, 7th ed. revised by the Very Rev. R. W. Church and the Rev. F. Paget, in 3 v., v. I. Oxford, 1888.