The metamorphoses of Ernst Haeckel’s image in the Russophone space: 1869–2019
Readers community rating
0.0 (0 votes)


Date of publication
Public year
The metamorphoses of Ernst Haeckel’s image in the Russophone space: 1869–2019
Читать книгу   Download pdf
О чем книга?

This article aims to trace the evolution of the perception of E. Haeckel by the Russian authorities, various social groups and scientists, depending on the sociocultural context and the stage of evolutionary synthesis. In Russia, many scientists initially perceived Haeckel as a German Darwin. However, Haeckel’s philosophical and ideological works prevailed among numerous translations of his works into Russian and were prohibited by the imperial authorities and criticized by conservative circles while the radicals tried to use them in their ideological and political struggle and antireligious propaganda. The main source of diffusion of his ideas and concepts into the Russophone space was the scientific literature concerned with the problems of correlation of ontogeny and phylogeny, trends and pathways of macroevolution, progress criteria, abiogenesis, anthropogenesis etc. Many of his notions and concepts were recognized to be of universal cultural importance. To an extent, they predetermined the distinguishing features of evolutionary synthesis in the Russian-speaking world. After the 1917 Revolution, numerous attempts were made in Russia to use Haeckel’s monism to dialecticize natural science, defend the principle of the inheritance of acquired characters, and substantiate the Lysenkoism. However, for almost 80 years his books have not been published in Russian, and his works have never been subjected to a serious history-of-science study. The metamorphoses of E. Haeckel’s image in the Russian-speaking world reflect a complicated path of perception of his works, determined by the established national scientific traditions, development of knowledge about evolution, and changing ideological and political contexts.

Об авторах
Eduard Kolchinskii
S. I. Vavilov Institute for the History of Science and Technology, Russian Academy of Sciences, Saint-Petersburg

1. Aleksandrov, M. L. (1911) Nauka i filosofiia [Science and Philosophy]. Moskva: Tekhnik.

2. Amon, E. O., Afanas’eva, M. S., Vishnevskaia, V. S., and Palechek, T. N. (2009) K 175-letiiu so dnia rozhdeniia Ernsta Gekkeliа (1834–1919) [Towards the 175th Anniversary of Birth of Ernst

3. Haeckel (1834–1919)], Litosfera, no. 5, pp. 109–113.

4. Biol’she, V. (Bölsche, W.) (1910) Ernst Haeckel: ego zhizn’ i uchenie [Ernst Haeckel: His Life and Teachings]. Sankt-Peterburg: Progress.

5. Biriukov, P. I. (1908) Lev Nikolaevich Tolstoi. Biografiia [Leo Tolstoy. A Biography]. Moskva: Posrednik, vol. 2.

6. Bliakher, L. Ia. (1972) Problema nasledovaniia priobretennykh priznakov [The Problem of Inheritance of Acquired Characters]. Moskva: Nauka.

7. Borodin, I. P. (1894) Protoplasma i vitalism [Protoplasm and Vitalism], Mir Bozhii, May, pp. 1–28.

8. Bronzov, А. А (1908) Khristianskaia zapoved’ o liubvi – novaia zapoved’ (protiv Gekkelia, Saladina i pr.) [The Christian Commandment of Love, a New Commandment (in Opposition to Haeckel,

9. Saladin and Others)]. Moskva: Tipografiia Moskovskogo universiteta.

10. Butkevich, T. I (1900) Filosofiia monizma [The Philosophy of Monism]. Khar’kov: Tipografiia Gubernskogo pravleniia.

11. D. G. (1906) Ot perevodchika [From the Translator], in: Gekkel’, E. (Haeckel, E.) Mirovye zagadki [The Riddle of the Universe]. Moskva: D. P. Efimov, pp. I–II.

12. Dennert, E (1909) Gekkel’ i ego zagadki po suzhdeniiam spetsialistov [Haeckel and His Riddles According to the Experts]. Moskva.

13. Di Gregorio, M. A. (2005) From Here to Eternity. Ernst Haeckel and Scientific Faith. Göttingen: Vandenhoock and Ruprecht.

14. Dobrovol’skii, L. M. (1962) Zapreshchennaia kniga v Rossii. 1825–1904: arkhivno-bibliograficheskie razyskaniia [The Banned Book in Russia (1825–1904): Archival and Bibliographic Studies]. Moskva: Izdatel’stvo Vsesoiuznoi knizhnoi palaty, vol. 1.

15. Dodel’, A. (1909) Haeckel kak vospitatel’ [Haeckel as an Educator]. Sankt-Peterburg: Ia. Chumakov.

16. Ezhikov, I. I. (1940) Uchenie o rekapituliatsii i ego kritiki [The Doctrine of Recapitulation and Its Critics], in: Miuller, F. (Müller, F.), and Gekkel’, E. (Haeckel, E.) Osnovnoi biogeneticheskii zakon [The Fundamental Biogenetic Law]. Moskva and Leningrad: Izdatel’stvo AN SSSR, pp. 7–42.

17. Famintsyn, A. S. (1898) Sovremennoe estestvoznanie i psikhologiia [Modern Science and Psychology]. Sankt-Peterburg: Mir Bozhii.

18. Filipchenko, Iu. A. (1977) Evoliutsionnaia ideia v biologii [The Evolutionary Idea in Biology]. Moskva: Nauka.

19. Filippov, M. M. (1902) Predislovie redaktora perevoda [A Foreword by the Translation Editor], in: Gekkel’, E. (Haeckel, E.) Mirovye zagadki [The Riddle of the Universe]. Moskva: D. P. Efimov, pp. I–VI.

20. Fokin, S. I. (2008) Russian Biologists at Villafranca, Proceedings of the California Academy of Sciences, 4th ser., vol. 59, no. 11, pp. 167–190.

21. Gasman, D. (1998) Haeckel’s Monism and the Birth of Fascist Ideology. New York: Peter Lang.

22. Gekkel’, E. (Haechel, E.) (1869) Uchenie ob organicheskikh formakh, osnovannoe na teorii prevrashcheniia vidov. Sostavleno po sochineniiu Ernsta Gekkelia “Generelle Morphologie” pod redaktsiei Il’i Mechnikova [The Concept of Organic Forms, Based on the Theory of Species Transformation. A Compilation Based on Ernst Haeckel’s “Generelle morphologie”, Edited by Ilya Mechnikov]. Sankt-Peterburg: A. Zalenskii.

23. Gekkel’, E. (Haeckel, E.) (1879) Istoriia plemennogo razvitiia organizmov [The History of Tribal Development of the Organisms]. Sankt-Peterburg: Tipografiia V. S. Balasheva.

24. Gekkel’, E (Haeckel, E.) (1899) Naturalist pod tropikami. Izvlechenie iz “Indische Reisebriefe” [A Naturalist in the Tropics: An Excerpt from “Indische Reisebriefe”]. Moskva: Russkaia mysl’.

25. Gekkel’, E. (Haeckel, E.) (1900). Transformizm i darvinizm [Transformism and Darwinism]. Sankt-Peterburg: Тipografiia I. N. Skorokhodova.

26. Gekkel’, E. (Haeckel, E) (1904) Pod solntsem Indii. Putevye pis’ma. [Under the Sun of India. Travel Notes]. Sankt-Peterburg: Vskhody.

27. Gekkel’, E. (Haeckel, E) (1905) Chudesa zhizni. Obshchedostupnye etiudy po filosofii biologii [The Wonders of Life: Popular Sketches on the Philosophy of Biology]. Sankt-Peterburg: Nauka i zhizn’.

28. Gekkel’, E. (Haeckel, E) (1906) Bog v prirode [God in the Nature]. Sankt-Peterburg: Vestnik znanii.

29. Gekkel’, E. (Haeckel, E.) (1907) I. Monizm kak sviaz’ mezhdu religiei i naukoi. Veroispovedanie estestvoispytatelia. II. Soiuz monistov. Polozhenie dlia organizatsii monizma. [I. Monism as a Link between Religion and Science. A Naturalist’s Confession of Faith. II. A Universal Monistic Alliance: Theses for the Organization of Monism]. Odessa: Tipografiia I. Kopel‘man.

30. Gekkel’, E. (Haeckel, E) (1907) Bor’ba za ideiu razvitiia: lektsii o proiskhozhdenii cheloveka i ego polozhenii v prirode [Struggle for the Idea of Development: Lectures on the Origin of Man and His Place in Nature]. Sankt-Peterburg: Vestnik znanii.

31. Gekkel’, E. (Haeckel, E.) (1908) Chudesa zhizni. Ocherki biologicheskoi filosofii [The Wonders of Life: A Popular Study of Biological Philosophy]. Sankt-Peterburg: Sankt-Peterburgskaia knizhnaia ekspeditsiia.

32. Gekkel’, E. (Haeckel, E.) (1908–1909) Еstestvennaia istoria tvoreniia. Obshcheponiatnoe nauchnoe izlozhenie ucheniia o razviti Gekkelia. Ch. 1–2 [The Natural History of Creation. A Comprehensible Scientific Recounting of Haeckel’s Doctrine of Evolution. Vols. 1–2]. Sankt-Peterburg: Tipografiia V. P. Veisbrut.

33. Gekkel’, E. (Haeckel, E) (1909) Bor’ba za evoliutsionnuiu ideiu [Struggle for the Evolutionary Idea]. Sankt-Peterburg: Sankt-Peterburgskaia ekspeditsiia.

34. Gekkel’, E. (Haeckel, E) (1909) Mirovozzrenie Darvina i Lamarka [The Worldviews of Darwin and Lamarck]. Sankt-Peterburg: Novaia zhizn’.

35. Gekkel’, E. (Haeckel, E) (1913) Lektsii po estestvoznaniiu i filosofii [Lectures in Science and Philosophy]. Sankt-Peterburg: Vestnik znanii.

36. Gekkel’, E. (Haeckel, E.) (1919) Proiskhozhdenie cheloveka [The Origin of Man]. Petrograd: Petrogradskii sovet rabochikh i soldatskikh deputatov.

37. Gekkel’, E. (Haeckel, E.) (1920) Mirovye zagadki. S poslesloviem “Ispoved’ chistogo razuma” [The Riddle of the Universe. With the afterword “The Confession of the Pure Reason”]. Moskva: Russkii bibliograficheckii institut brat’ev A. N. i I. N. Granat.

38. Gekkel’, E. (Haeckel, E) (1925) Naturalist pod tropikami. Izvlechenie iz “Indische Reisebriefe” Ernsta Gekkelia [A Naturalist in the Tropics: An Excerpt from “Indische Reisebriefe” by Ernst Haeckel]. Moskva and Leningrad: Gosizdat.

39. Gekkel’, E. (Haeckel, E.) (1935) Mirovye zagadki [The Riddle of the Universe]. Moskva: Gudok.

40. Gekkel’, E. (Haeckel, E.) (1937) Mirovye zagadki [The Riddle of the Universe]. Moskva: Gosudarstvennoe antireligioznoe izdatel’stvo.

41. Gekkel’, E. (Haeckel, E.) (2007) Krasota form v prirode [The Beauty of Forms in Nature]. Sankt-Peterburg: Izdatel’stvo V. Regena.

42. Gekkel’, E. (Haeckel, E.) (2015) Mirovye zagadki. Populiarnye ocherki monisticheskoi filosofii [The Riddle of the Universe. A Popular Study of Monistic Philosophy]. Sankt-Peterburg: Liblok.

43. Gekkel’, E. (Haeckel, E.) (2017) Еstestvennaia istoria tvoreniia. Obshcheponiatnoe nauchnoe izlozhenie ucheniia o razviti Gekkelia [The History of Creation. A Comprehensible Scientific Recounting of Haeckel’s Doctrine of Evolution]. Sаnkt-Peterburg: Al’faret.

44. Gliboff, S. H (2008) G. Bronn, Ernst Haeckel, and the Origins of German Darwinism. A Study in Translation and Transformation. Cambridge, MA and London: MIT Press.

45. Grigor’ev, K. G. (1913) O monizme E. Gekkelia [On the Monism of Ernst Haeckel]. Kazan’: Tsentral’naia tipografiia.

46. Gureеv, G. A. (1924) Ernst Gekkel’ kak myslitel’ [Ernst Haeckel as a Thinker], in: Gekkel’, E. (Haeckel, E.) Monizm [Monism]. Gomel’: Gomel’skii rabochii, pp. 3–34.

47. Haeckel, E. (1866) Generelle Morphologie der Organismen. Allgemeine Grundzüge der organischen Formen-Wissenschaft, mechanisch begründet durch die von Charles Darwin reformierte Deszendenz-Theorie. Bd. 1–2. Berlin: Georg Reimer.

48. Haeckel, E. (1868) Natürliche Schöpfungsgeschichte. Natürliche Schöpfungsgeschichte. Gemeinverständliche wissenschaftliche Vorträge über die Entwicklungslehre im Allgemeinen und diejenige von Darwin, Goethe und Lamarck in besonderen, über die Anwendung derselben auf den Ursprung des Menschen und andere damit zusammenhängende Grundfragen der Naturwissenschaft. Berlin: Georg Reimer

49. Haeckel, E. (1874) Anthropogenie oder Entwickelungsgeschichte des Menschen: gemeinständliche wissenschaftliche Vorträge über die Grundzüge der menschlichen Keimes- und Stammes-Geschichte. Leipzig: Wilhelm Engelmann.

50. Haeckel, E. (1874) Die Gastraea-Theorie, die phylogenetische Klassification des Tierreichs und die Homologie der Keimblätter, Jenaische Zeitschrift für Naturwissenschaft, vol. 8, pp. 1–58.

51. Haeckel, E. (1899) Die Welträtsel. Gemeinverständliche Studien über monistische Philosopie. Bonn: E. Strauß.

52. Haeckel, E. (1906) Monismus und Naturgeserze. Brackwede: W. Breitenbach.

53. Haeckel, E. (1914) Weltkrieg und Naturgeschichte, Nord und Süd, no. 151 (481), pp. 140–147.

54. Haeckel, E. (1915) Ewigkeit. Weltkriegsgedanken über Leben und Tod, Religion und Entwicklungslehre. Berlin: Georg Reimer.

55. Hauser, K. (1920) Ernst Haeckel: sein Leben, sein Wirken und seine Bedeutung für den Geisteskampf der Gegenwart. Godesberg bei Bonn: Naturwissenschaftlicher Verlag.

56. Hopwood, N. (2015) Haeckel’s Embryos. Image, Evolution and Fraud. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

57. Hoßfeld, U. (2010) Absolute Ernst Haeckel. Freiburg: Orange Press.

58. Hoßfeld, U., and Breidbach, O. (2005) Haeckel-Korrespondenz. Berlin: VWB-Verlag.

59. Iablokov, A. V., and Iusufov, A. G. (2004) Evoliutsionnoe uchenie [The Doctrine of Evolution]. Moskva: Vysshaia shkola.

60. Iung, K G. (Jung, C. G.) (1997) Dusha i mif: shest’ arhetipov [Soul and Myth: Six Archetypes]. Moskva: Sovershenstvo and Kiev: Port-Royal’.

61. Kholodkovskii, N. A. (1923) Biologicheskie ocherki. Sbornik izbrannykh rabot [Biological Essays. Selected Articles]. Moskva and Petrograd: Gosizdat.

62. Khvol’son, O. D. (1911) Gegel’, Gekkel’, Kossut i dvenadtsataia zapoved’ [Hegel, Haeckel, Kossut, and the Twelfth Commandment]. Sankt-Peterburg: Physice.

63. Kleeberg, B. (2007) God-Nature Progressing: Natural Theology in German Monism, Science in Context, vol. 23, no. 3, pp. 537–569.

64. Kolchinskii, E. I. (2009) Iubilei Ch. Darvina v sotsial’no-kul’turnykh i kognitivnykh kontekstakh [Charles Darwin’s Jubilees in the Sociocultural and Cognitive Contexts], Istoriko-biologicheskie issledovania (Studies in the History of Biology), vol. 1, no. 1, pp. 15–48.

65. Kolchinskii, E. I. (2014) Edinstvo evoliutsionnoi teorii v razdelennom mire XX veka [The Unity of Evolutionary Theory in the Divided World of 20th Century]. Sankt-Peterburg: Nestor-Istoriia.

66. Kolchinskii, E. I. (2015) Sovetskie iubilei Ch. Darvina i lysenkoizm [Darwin’s Jubilees in the USSR and Lysenkoism], Istoriko-biologicheskie issledovania (Studies in the History of Biology), vol. 7, no. 2, pp. 10–52.

67. Kolchinskii, E. I. (ed.) (1983) Razvitie evoliutsionnoi teorii v SSSR (1917–1970-e gody) [The Development of Evolutionary Theory in the USSR (1917–1970)]. Leningrad: Nauka.

68. Kolchinsky, E. I. (2014) Nikolai Vavilov in the Years of Stalin’s ‘Revolution from Above’ (1929–1932), Centaurus, 2014, vol. 56, no. 4, pp. 330–358.

69. Kolchinsky, E. I., Kutschera, U., Hossfeld, U., and Levit G. S. (2017) Russia’s New Lysenkoism, Сurrent Biology, vol. 27, no. 19, pp. R1042–R1047.

70. Kolchinsky, Е. I., and Levit, G. S. (2019) The Reception of Haeckel in Pre-Revolutionary Russia and His Impact on Evolutionary Theory, Theory in Biosciences, vol. 138, no. 1, pp. 73–88.

71. Kutschera, U., Levit, G. S., and Hossfeld, U. (2019) Ernst Haeckel (1834–1919): The German Darwin and His Impact on Modern Biology, Theory in Biosciences, vol. 138, no. 1, pp. 1–7.

72. Levit, G. S, Hoßfeld, U. (2017) Major Research Traditions in Twentieth-Century Evolutionary Biology: The Relations of Germany’s Darwinism with Them, in: Delisle R. G. (ed.) The Darwinian

73. Tradition in Context Research Programs in Evolutionary Biology. Cham: Springer, pp. 169–193.

74. Lipskii, N. I. (1913) Naturalisticheskii monizm Gekkelia [E. Haeckel’s Naturalistic Monism]. Khar’kov: Mirnyi trud.

75. Lodzh, O. (Lodge, O.) (1908) Zhizn’ i materiia. Kritika mirovykh zagadok [Life and Matter. A Criticism of Professor Haeckel's “Riddle of the Universe”]. Moskva: Tvorcheskaia mysl’.

76. Maksimov, A. A. (1937) Gekkel’ i ego “Mirovye zagadki” [Haeckel and His “Riddle of the Universe”], in: Haeckel, E. Mirovye zagadki [The Riddle of the Universe]. Moskva: OGIZ, pp. 5–54.

77. Manoilenko, K. V. (2016) Andrei Sergeevich Famintsyn [Andrei Sergeevich Famintsyn]. Sankt-Peterburg: Nestor-Istoriia.

78. Maurer, F., von (1914) Ernst Haeckel und die Biologie: Festrede zur Feier von Ernst Haeckels 80. Geburtstag. Jena: Fischer.

79. Mechnikov, I. I. (1943) O darvinizme [On Darwinism]. Moskva and Leningrad: Izdatel’stvo AN SSSR.

80. Mechnikov, I. I. (1950) Izbrannye biologicheskie proizvedeniia [Selected Biological Works]. Moskva: Izdatel’stvo AN SSSR.

81. Menzbir, M. A. (1897) Tseilonskie vedy i iskopaemоe chelovekopodobnoe sushchestvo s o. Iava (zooantropologicheskii ocherk) [The Ceylonese Vedda and a Fossil Humanoid Creature from the Island of Java (A Zooanthropological Essay)], Russkaia mysl’, vol. 8, no. 3, pp. 129–163.

82. Menzbir, M. A. (1900) Glavneishie predstaviteli darvinizma v Zapadnoi Evrope: Ernst Gekkel’ [The Main Representatives of Darwinism in Western Europe: Ernst Haeckel], Russkaia mysl’, vol. 6, no. 2, pp. 1–17.

83. Miklukho-Maklai, N. N. (1950) Sobranie sochinenii. V 5 t. [Collected works. In 5 vols.]. Moskva and Leningrad: Izdatel’stvo AN SSSR, vol. 2.

84. Miuller, F. (Müller, F.), and Gekkel’, E. (Haeckel, E.) (1940) Osnovnoi biogeneticheskii zakon [The Fundamental Biogenetic Law]. Moskva and Leningrad: Izdatel’stvo AN SSSR.

85. Muzrukova, E. B. (2013) Iulius Shaksel’. Zhizn’ i sud’ba [Julius Schaxel. Life and Fate], Istoriko-biogicheskie issledovaniia (Studies in the History of Biolog), vol. 5, no. 3, pp. 72–80.

86. Ostwald, W. (1914) Ernst Haeckel. Festrede, gehalten bei der Feier von Ernst Haeckels 80. Geburtstag in Hamburg am 19.2.1914. Leipzig: Unesma.

87. Plekhanov, G. V. (1928) Osnovnye voprosy marksizma [The Fundamental Problems of Marxism], in: Plekhanov, G. V. Sochineniia. V 24 t. [Works. In 24 vols.]. Moskva and Leningrad: Gosizdat, vol. 18, pp. 182–252.

88. Poliakov, I. M (1941) Kurs darwinisma [A Course in Darwinism]. Mockva: Uchpedgiz.

89. Polianskii, Iu. I. (1955) Pis’ma A. O. Kovalevskogo k I. I. Mechnikovu.1866–1900 [A. O. Kovalevsky’s Letters to I. I. Mechnikov]. Moskva and Leningrad. Izdatel’svo AN SSSR.

90. Polianskii, V. I., and Polianskii, Iu. I (eds.) (1966) Istoriia evoliutsionnykh uchenii v biologii [The History of Evolutionary Doctrines in Biology]. Moskva: Izdatel’stvo AN SSSR.

91. Reinke, I. (1909) Naturfilosofiia [Natural Philosophy]. Sankt-Peterburg: Priroda.

92. Reiß, Сh., Springer, S., Hoßfeld, U., Olsson, L., and Levit, G. (2007) Introduction to Julius Schaxel’s Autobiography, Theory in Bioscience, vol. 126, no. 4, pp. 165–175.

93. Richards, R. J. (2008) The Tragic Sense of Life: Ernst Haeckel and the Struggle over Evolutionary Thought. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.

94. Rieppel, O. (2016) Phylogenetic Systematics: Haeckel to Hennig. Boca Raton: CRC Press Publisher.

95. Schmalgauzen, I. I. (1946) Problemy darvinizma. Posobie dlia vysshei shkoly [The Problems of Darwinism. Textbook for the Higher School]. Moskva: Sovetskaia nauka.

96. Schmidt, H., von (1934). Denkmal eines grossen Lebens. Jena: Frommannsche Buchhandlung.

97. Shiltov, A. M. (1907) Ernst Gekkel’ pered sudom logiki [Ernst Haeckel before the Tribunal of Logic]. Khar’kov: Tipografiia N. V. Petrova.

98. Shimkevich, V. M. (1907) K russkomu izdaniiu [Towards the Russian Edition], in: Gekkel’, E. (Haeckel, E.) Mirovye zagadki [The Riddle of the Universe]. Moskva: I. D. Ivanov, pp. I–VII.

99. Tareev, M. M. (1908) Ernst Gekkel’. Monisticheskaia etika [Ernst Haeckel. The Monistic Ethic]. Sergiev Posad: Tipografiia Sviato-Troitskoi Sergievoi lavry.

100. Vedenov, M. F (1963) Bor’ba Ernsta Gekkelia za materializm v biologii [Ernst Haeckel’s Struggle for Materialism in Biology]. Moskva: Izdatel’stvo AN SSSR.

101. Vorontsov, N. N. (1984) Ernst Gekkel’ i sud’by ucheniia Darvina [Ernst Haeckel and the Fate of Darwin’s Theory], Priroda, no. 8, pp. 75–87.

102. Vorontsov, N. N. (1999) Razvitie ehvoliutsionnykh idei v biologii [The Development of Evolutionary Ideas in Biology]. Moskva: Progress-Traditsiia.

103. Zavadskii, K. M. (1973) Razvitie evoliutsionnoi teorii posle Darvina (1859–1920-e gody) [The Development of Evolutionary Theory after Darwin (1859–1920)]. Leningrad: Nauka.