The Balfour Declaration in up-to-date political discourse
The Balfour Declaration in up-to-date political discourse
Читать книгу   Download pdf
О чем книга?

The paper studies the contemporary political discourse on the Balfour Declaration of 1917. The author argues that renewed interest in the declaration has appeared since 2008, when a media campaign began to accuse the UK of issuing the document. The campaigners claim that the British promise of support for the creation of a “Jewish national home” in 1917 was the beginning of the tragedy of the Palestinian people, and demanded that London pay compensation to the Palestinians. The author of the article confirms the hypothesis proposed by some publicists that such statements are part of a broader information strategy seeking to contest Israel’s legitimacy and to garner international recognition for the Palestinian state. The article also examines the current historical narrative on the Balfour Declaration, and explores three lines: a “postcolonial” narrative, a neo-Zionist line, and a Christian-Zionist direction. The article attempts to formulate the main theses of each narrative.

Об авторах
Dmitry Sheveliov
Assistant Professor of International Politics at Belarusian State University
Belarusian State University

1. UNESCO. Executive Board. Doсument 200 EX/PX/DR.25.2Rev. (in Russian).

2. Naser G.A. The problem of the Egyptian Revolution: Speeches and addresses. Moscow, 1979 (in Russian).

3. The McMahon–Hussein Correspondence, 1915–1916 and the Question of Palestine. Preface, introduction, an authorized translation of documents and comments by Dz. Shavialiou. Moscow, 2008 (in Russian).

4. Radutskii M. The Kingdom of Jordan – Arab Palestinian State. 18 Dec 2011] .

5. Samarskaia L.M. The Balfour Declaration in the Context of Anglo-Zionist Diplomacy during the period of World War I. Moscow, 2016 (in Russian).

6. Shandra A.V. New Approaches towards the Interpretation of the Balfour Declaration in Contemporary Russian Historiography. Political life in Western Europe: Antiquity, Middle Ages, Modern and Contemporary Times): Vol. 11. Arzamas, 2016. Pp. 116-120 (in Russian).

7. Shapovalov M.S. Palestinian Issue in British Middle Eastern Policy in 1914-1931. Abstracts of thesis… 07.00.03. Tomsk, 2008 (in Russian).

8. Shapovalov M.S. Palestinian Legacy in the Policy of Provisional Government (March–April 1917). Recent History of Russia. Saint Petersburg, 2017. No. 2. Pp. 19–32 (in Russian).

9. Shavialiou D. The Balfour Declaration November 2, 1917 and Zionist Draft July 18, 1917: Semantic Analysis of Two Texts. Belarusian Journal of international Law and International Relations. 2000. No. 1. Pp. 82–86 (in Russian).

10. Alfarra J. Explained: The Balfour Declaration. 2 Nov 2016 .

11. Arens M. The Palestinians Can Thank Israel for their Skirting the Arab Catastrophe. 15 Aug 2016. .

12. Arthur Balfour Apologizes to Palestinian Child. 10 Jul 2017 .

13. Balfour Declaration: 99 Years of Colonialism, 99 Years of Resistance. 3 Nov 2016 .

14. Balfour Declaration ‘a Humanitarian Act’, Says Current Lord Balfour. 7 Feb 2017 .

15. Baroud R. Why Palestinians Want to Sue Britain: 99 Years since the Balfour Declaration. 2 Nov 2016 .

16. Baroud R. The Balfour Declaration Destroyed Palestine, Not the Palestinian People. 11 Oct 2017 .

17. Beinin J. & Hajjar L. Palestine, Israel and the Arab-Israeli Conflict: A Primer. Middle East Research and Information Project (MERIP). 2014. .

18. Beсhоr G. Leksikon ASHAF (Лексикон ООП). Тель-Авив, 1995?. (ивр.)

19. Ben David L. Historical Perspective on the Balfour Declaration. The Geller Report. 29 Jan 2017 .

20. Black I. Will Palestinians Sue Britain over the Balfour Declaration of 1917? 27 Jul 2016 .

21. Blum R. Right from Wrong: The Palestinians’ War on the Balfour Declaration. 30 Oct 2016 .

22. Cohen J. Mark Regev Reveals UK and Israel Working on Public Celebration of Balfour, 8 Jun 2016. .

23. Eglash R. Most Palestinians Still Blame Britain for the Israeli Occupation, Poll Finds. 18 Oct 2016. .

24. Erekat S. (1). As Long as Israel Continues its Settlements, a Two-State Solution Is Impossible. 24 Oct 2016 .

25. Erekat S. (2). Balfour Declaration: Why Britain Cannot Continue to Avoid Its Responsibility. 2 Nov 2016 .

26. Inviting Netanyahu to Celebrate Balfour in London ‘a New Slap for Palestinians’. 11 Feb 2017 .

27. Jeremy Corbyn’s Attendance at Mend Event Condemned as ‘Utterly Unacceptable’, The Jewish Chronicle. 2 Nov 2017 .

28. Julius L. The Palestinian Distortion of the Balfour Declaration. 29 Jul 2016 .

29. Keinon H. Netanyahu to Go to London Next Week for Balfour Declaration Centennial. 23 Oct 2017 .

30. Kemp R. Balfour Declaration, November 2016. 6 Nov 2016 .

31. Knell Y. Balfour Declaration: The Divisive Legacy of 67 Words. 2 Nov 2017 .

32. Koestler A. Promise and Fulfilment. Palestine 1917–1949. N.Y.: The McMillan Co., 1949.

33. Labour’s Jeremy Corbyn Refuses to Attend Balfour Celebration Dinner. 29 Oct 2017 .

34. Littlewood S. Despicable Balfour: A Story of Betrayal. 31 Oct 2016 .

35. Makow H. British Jews Tried to Stop Balfour Declaration. [2006] .

36. Mandhai Sh. Palestinians Demand UK Apology for Balfour Declaration. 1 Nov 2016 .

37. Middle East Media Research Institute – TV Monitor Project. Clip #5592. PA President Abbas’ Speech at Arab Summit: We Are Preparing to Sue British Government for Balfour Declaration. 24 Jul 2016. .

38. National Plan of Action for Palestinian Children 2004–2010: Ministry of Planning. Secretariat of the National Plan of Action for Palestinian Children, July 2004. Ramallah, 2004. .

39. Palestinians Gear Up to Sue the UK – over 1917 Balfour Declaration. 25 Jul 2016 .

40. Parsons D. No Apologies for Balfour. 30 Oct 2017 .

41. Petition: UK Government Should ‘Apologise’ to Palestinians for Balfour Declaration. 18 Feb 2017 .

42. Rasgon A. Senior PA Official to Britain: We Want Our Own Balfour. 23 Aug 2017 .

43. Renton J. The Balfour Declaration: Origins and Consequences. 25 Mar 2008 .

44. Results of Palestinian Public Opinion Poll No. 53. 13–15 October 2016. An-Najah National University; Center for Opinion Polls and Survey Studies. .

45. Roth D. J. Corbyn Visit to Grave of PLO Terrorist from Munich Attack Stirs Uproar. 29 May 2017 .

46. Session in Human Rights Council on Balfour Declaration Centenary. 26 Sep 2017 .

47. Singer D. Britain Rebuffs Abbas Call to Apologize for Balfour Declaration. 23 Dec 2016 .

48. Why the Palestinians Should Thank Britain for the Balfour Declaration, Not Sue her! 24 Aug 2016 .

49. Zieve T. WZO Finally Responds to Lord Balfour. 25 Oct 2017

50. Zogby J. The Fateful Decision: British House of Commons Votes on Palestine. 11 Dec 2014 .

51. Zogby J. Balfour Declaration: A Convergence of Zionist Ambition and the British Imperial Enterprise. 28 Oct 2017 .

52. 100 Years of Injustice: [Flyer made by the Embassy of the State of Palestine in Slovakia]. [2017]. 4 p.