National identity, collective memory and history wars in East Asia
National identity, collective memory and history wars in East Asia
Читать книгу   Download pdf
О чем книга?

The article addresses the phenomenon of “history wars” between China and the Republic of Korea, on the one side, and Japan, on the other, which broke out after the cold war around the historical interpretation of Japan’s expansionist policy on the mainland, especially in the period of WWII. The aim of the article is to examine the origin, the ethical and the political underpinnings of “history wars”, specifically in the context of collective memories of WWII and the national identities in the three countries. The authors tried to trace the prehistory of the formation of national identities in East Asia in the twentieth century.

While South Korea and China perceive the period of Japan’s imperialist expansion in the XX century through the dualistic prism of the relationship between the victim and the criminal, in Japan the policy on the mainland, although considered to be "erroneous", is not subject to unconditional condemnation on the grounds that at that time all the imperialist states acted the same way. Besides, the discourse of victimhood based on war sufferings of the Japanese people is in conflict with the wounded feelings of the East Asian nations.

The article articulates the role of patriotic education and, specifically, the policy of creating museums and historical memorials in the three countries in conducting “history wars”. The authors insist that the interplay of domestic discourse and international memory politics has become a durable source of paramount tension in the international relations of the region.

Об авторах
Dmitry Streltsov
Head of Department of Afro-Asian Studies
Leading Research Fellow of the Institute of Oriental Studies RAS. Head of Department of Afro-Asian Studies, MGIMO University
Sergey V. Grishachev
Associate Professor at the HSE School of Oriental Studies
References

1. Abe Sh. Utsukushii kune-e. Tokyo: Bunshun shinsho, 2006 [Abe Sh. Towards a Beautiful Country. Tokyo: Bunshun shinsho, 2006 (in Japanese)].

2. Coble P.M. China’s ‘New Remembering’ of the Anti-Japanese War of Resistance, 1937–1945. The China Quarterly. 2007. No. 190. Pp. 394–410.

3. Collingwood R.G. History as Re-enactment of Past Experience. The Idea of History. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1946. Pp. 282–302. https://brocku.ca/MeadProject/Collingwood/1946_4.html (accessed: 25.04.2021).

4. Denton K.A. Heroic Resistance and Victims of Atrocity: Negotiating the Memory of Japanese Imperialism in Chinese Museums. Japan Focus. 2007. October 1. Vol. 5. Issue 10. https://apjjf.org/-Kirk-A.-Denton/2547/article.html (accessed: 25.04.2021).

5. Dian M. Interpreting Japan’s Contested Memory: Conservative and Progressive Traditions. International Relations. 2015. No. 29(3). Pp. 363–377.

6. Duus P. Introduction: History Wars in Postwar East Asia, 1945–2014. ‘History Wars’ and Reconciliation in Japan and Korea. The Roles of Historians, Artists and Activists. Ed. by M. Lewis. New York: Palgrave Macmillan US, 2017. Pp. 1–16.

7. Fitzgerald J. China’s Anti-Fascist War Narrative: Seventy Years on and the War with Japan is Not Over Yet. The ASAN Forum. 2015. November 17. http://www.theasanforum.org/chinas-anti-fascist-war-narrativeseventy-years-on-and-the-war-with-japan-is-not-over-yet/ (accessed: 25.04.2021).

8. He Yinan. Remembering and Forgetting the War: Elite Mythmaking, Mass Reaction, and Sino-Japanese Relations, 1950–2006. History and Memory. Vol. 19, no. 2. Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 2007. Pp. 43–74.

9. Hong Kal. Commemoration and the Construction of Nationalism: War Memorial Museums in Korea and Japan. Japan Focus. 2008. Sep. 01. Vol. 6. Issue 9. https://apjjf.org/-Hong-KAL/2880/article.html (accessed: 25.04.2021).

10. Hu Jintao. Speech at a Meeting Marking the 60th Anniversary of the Victory of the Chinese People’s War of Resistance Against Japanese Aggression and the World Anti-fascist War. September 3, 2005. http://na.chineseembassy.org/eng/sgxw/t210707.htm (accessed: 25.04.2021).

11. Ja-hyun Chun, Young Chul Cho. Different Historical Prisms and Regressive Political Reconciliation in Northeast Asia. Journal of Asia-Pacific Studies. 2016. Vol. 23. No. 3. Pp. 71–107.

12. Jansen M. The Making of Modern Japan. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 2000.

13. Ji Yuqiao. South Korea to Remember Joint Fight against Japanese Aggression with China. Global Times. January 26. 2021. https://www.globaltimes.cn/page/202101/1214015.shtml (accessed: 25.04.2021).

14. Lewentowicz S.E. In Response to Yasukuni: the Curious Approach the Chinese and South Korean Governments Take Toward an Unresolved Link to the Past. Master’s Thesis. Naval Postgraduate School Monterey, CA. 2013. https://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/36727313.pdf (accessed: 25.04.2021).

15. Li R. Identity Tensions and China-Japan-Korea Relations: Can Peace be Maintained in North East Asia? Identity, Trust, and Reconciliation in East Asia. Rethinking Peace and Conflict Studies. Ed. by K. Clements. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2018. Pp. 47–73.

16. Mao Tse-tung. On Protracted War. May 1938. https://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/mao/selected-works/volume-2/mswv2_09.htm (accessed: 25.04.2021).

17. Moore G. History, Nationalism and Face in Sino-Japanese Relations. Journal of Chinese Political Science. 2010. Vol. 15. Pp. 283–306.

18. Perminova V. War Remembrance in China and Its Influence on Contemporary Sino-Japanese Relations. Istoriya. 2020. Vol. 98. No. 12–1. Pp. 1–20 (in Russian). https://history.jes.su/s207987840010292-0-1/ (accessed: 25.04.2021).

19. Rauhala E. 104 Years Later, a Chinese Train Station Platform is Still the Site of Anti-Japanese Rancor. Time. January 30, 2014. https://time.com/2609/104-years-later-a-chinese-train-station-platform-is-still-thesite-of-anti-japanese-rancor/ (accessed: 25.04.2021).

20. Reilly J. Remember History, Not Hatred: Collective Remembrance of China’s War of Resistance to Japan. Modern Asian Studies. 2011. Vol. 45. Pp. 463–490.

21. Streltsov D. “The Diplomacy of Apologies” in the Foreign Policy of Postwar Japan. Yearbook Japan. 2020 (1). Vol. 49. Pp. 29–61 (in Russian).

22. Streltsov D.V. War Memory as an Independent Factor in Japan’s Relations with Neighbors: on the 75th Anniversary of Japan’s Surrender. Japanese Studies in Russia. 2020(2). No. 4. Pp. 78–97 (in Russian).

23. Tamaki T. An Unholy Pilgrimage? Yasukuni and the Construction of Japan’s Asia Imaginary. Asian Politics & Policy. 2009. Vol. 1. Issue 1. Pp. 31–49.

24. Tsujita M. A Fragile Balance between ‘Normalization’ and the Revival of Nationalistic Sentiments.

25. Modern Japan: Issues of History and Identity. Folkestone: Global Oriental, 2009. Pp. 187–198.

26. Yi, Bo R. The Memorialization of Historical Memories in East Asia. PhD, dissertation, International Studies, Old Dominion University, 2017. https://digitalcommons.odu.edu/gpis_etds/17 (accessed: 25.04.2021).

27. Yoshida T. Revising the Past, Complicating the Future: The Yushukan War Museum in Modern Japanese History. Japan Focus. 2007. December 1. Vol. 5. Issue 12. URL: https://apjjf.org/-Takashi-YOSHIDA/2594/article.html (accessed: 25.04.2021).

28. Zhao Suisheng. A State-Led Nationalism: the Patriotic Education Campaign in Post-Tiananmen China. Communist and Post-Communist Studies. 1998. Vol. 31. Issue 3. Pp. 287–302.