«Bukhara Is Like Algeria»: the Ottoman Political Elite on the Petition of the Bukhara Emir Khaidar to Sultan Mahmud II to Accept Bukhara into the Ottoman Empire.
«Bukhara Is Like Algeria»: the Ottoman Political Elite on the Petition of the Bukhara Emir Khaidar to Sultan Mahmud II to Accept Bukhara into the Ottoman Empire.
Читать книгу   Download pdf
О чем книга?

Relations between the Bukhara Emirate and the Ottoman Empire in the 19th century previously became the object of study more than once [Saray, 1994; 2003. Andican, 2003]. However, one curious episode of bilateral relations has not received the proper assessment of the researchers. We are talking about a very interesting message from the ruler of Bukhara, Mangyt Emir Haidar (1800-1826) to the Ottoman Sultan Mahmud II (1808-1839) with a request to accept Bukhara into the Ottoman Empire. Difficult internal and external political situation around Bukhara in the 1810s - 1820s. forced Emir Haidar to look for ways to solve it, one of which was to receive external assistance from the state, which was considered the most powerful in the Muslim world. Also interesting are the motives of the Ottoman political elite, who discussed various aspects of this diplomatic incident and made a direct comparison of the situation with the potential entry of Bukhara into the empire with the range of problems experienced by Ottoman diplomacy around Algeria. The similarity of the conditions for the entry of Algeria in the XVI century into the Ottoman Empire and the situation around Bukhara in the 19th century was due to the similarity of the military-political threats they faced. However, Bukhara was a little-known region of the world, the annexation of which carried significant risks. In this article, the author will attempt to consider this episode, the motives and goals of the parties in more detail.

Об авторах
Alexander D. Vasilyev
Senior Research Fellow, Institute of Oriental Studies, RAS; Director of the International Russian-Turkish Center, Russian State University for Humanities
Institute of Oriental Studies, RAS; Russian State University for the Humanities

1. Bartold V.V. Pan-Islamism. Selected Works, Vol.VI, Мoscow, «Nauka», 1966. Pp.400-402. [In Russian]

2. Bartold V.V. Caliph and Sultan. Selected Works, Vol.VI, Мoscow, «Nauka», 1966. Pp. 15-78. [In Russian]

3. Vasiliev A.D. Banner and Sword from the Padishah. Political and Cultural Contacts of the Khanates of Central Asia and the Ottoman Empire (mid-16th – early 20th Centuries). Moscow, Probel-2000, 2014. [In Russian]

4. Vasilyev A.D. Relations with Muslim Natives of the Russian Administration in Turkestan and the French in Algeria / French Yearbook 2014. Vol. 2. France and the Orient. Moscow, 2014. Pp. 279-300

5. Ivanov P.P. The Uprising of the Khitay Kipchaks in the Bukhara Khanate. 1821-1825. Sources and Experience of their Research. Moscow-Leningrad, Publishing House of the Academy of Sciences of USSR, 1937. [In Russian]

6. Ivanov P.P. Essays on the History of Central Asia. Moscow, Izdatelsvo Vostochnoy Literaturi, 1958. [In Russian]

7. History of Algeria in New and Recent Times / ed. A.M. Vasilyev. Moscow, Nauka, Glavnaya Redaktsiya Vostochnoy Literatury. 1992 [In Russian]

8. History of the Peoples of Uzbekistan. Tom. 2. From the Formation of the Sheibanid State to the Great October Socialist Revolution. Tashkent, Publishing house of the ANUzSSR, 1947 [In Russian]

9. History of the Ottoman State, Society and Civilization / ed. E.Ihsanoglu. Vol.1. Moscow, Vostochnaya Literatura, 2006 [In Russian]

10. History of Central Asia in Ottoman Documents. Volume 1. Political and diplomatic relations. Samarkand: IICAS, TAD, 2011 [In Russian]

11. Kugelgen, A. von. Legitimation of the Central Asian Dynasty of Mangits in the Works of their Historians (XVIII-XIX Centuries). Almaty, Publishing house «Daik-Press», 2004 [In Russian]

12. Mujani, S.A. Chronicle of Najd. The reign of Muhammad ibn Abd al-Wahhab and the establishment of the Saud dynasty in Najd and Hijaz in Ottoman archival documents / transl. from pers. V. Koklikov; scientific. ed. A. Vasilyev. M., OOO "Sadra", 2020 [In Russian]

13. Ryazhev A.S. The Mirage of a Religious War: the Situation in the South-East of the Russian Empire in the Estimates of the Border Authorities (late 1780 - early 1790s). [In Russian]] https://foreignasia.ru/nauchnye-trudy-po-teme-tsentralnaja-azija-v-mezhdunarodnyh-otnoshenijah/stat-i-2020/mirazh-religioznoj-vojny-obstanovka-na-yugo-vostoke-rossijskoj-imperii-v-otsenkakh-pogranichnykh-vlastej-konets-1780-nachalo-1790-kh-gg (accessed: 08.05.2021)

14. Khalfin N.A. Russia and the Khanates of Central Asia (First Half of the 19th Century). Moscow, Nauka, 1984 [In Russian]

15. Andican, Ahat A. Cedidizm’den Bağımsızlığa Hariçte Türkistan Mücadelesi. İstanbul, 2003.

16. Belgelerle Osmanlı-Türkistan İlişkileri (XVI.-XX. Yüzyıllar). Ankara, 2004.

17. BOA, HAT, dosya 170, belge 7280.

18. BOA, HAT, dosya 175, belge 7616.

19. BOA, HAT, dosya 781, gömlek 36546.

20. BOA, HAT, dosya 781, gömlek 36551.

21. BOA, HAT, dosya 781, gömlek 36551.

22. BOA, HAT, dosya 781, gömlek 36552.

23. BOA, HAT, dosya 781, gömlek 36581-А.

24. BOA, HAT, dosya 781, gömlek 36581-В

25. BOA, HAT, dosya 782, gömlek 36608.

26. BOA, HAT, dosya 961, gömlek 41191.

27. BOA, HAT, dosya 1274, gömlek 49436.

28. BOA, HAT, dosya 1417, gömlek 57968.

29. BOA, Name-i Hümayün, defter 10, s.288.

30. Gibb Hamilton A. R. Lütfi Paşa on Ottoman Caliphate / Oriens, XV (Dec. 31, 1962). P. 287–295.

31. Osmanlı Devleti ile Kafkasya, Türkistan ve Kırım hanlıkları arasındaki münasebetlere dair arşiv belgeleri. Ankara, 1992.

32. Osmanlı belgelerinde Cezayır. Ankara, T.C. Başbakanlık Devlet Arşivleri Genel Müdürlüğü,Osmanlı Arşivi Daire Başkanlığı, Yayın № 115. 2010.

33. Özmi A. Pan-islamizm. Osmanlı Devleti, Hindistan Müslümanları ve İngiltere (1877-1924). Ankara, 1977.

34. Saray M. Rus İşgali Devrinde Osmanlı Devleti ile Türkistan Hanlıkları Arasındaki Siyasi Münasebetler (1775-1875). Ankara, 1994.

35. Saray M. The Russian, British, Chinese and Ottoman Rivalry in Turkestan. Ankara, 2003.

36. Shukla R.L. Britain, India and the Turkish Empire. 1853-1882. New Delhi, 1973.

37. Süreyya, Mehmed. Sicill-i Osmani. Osmanlı ünlüleri. Cilt 5. İstanbul, Numune matbaacılık, 1996.

38. Uzundal, E. Osmanlı İlmiye Teşkilatından Bir Portre: Şeyhülislam Halil Efendi ve Terekesi / International Journal of History, Volume 10, Issue 8, November 2018. Pp. 178-196.

39. Türkler. Cilt 9. Ankara, Yeni Türkiye Yayınları, 2002.